Sarah Michelle Gellar and Jennifer Love Hewitt apparently haven’t spoken since 1997, when they costarred in I Know What You Did Last Summer. But that’s not because there’s any bad blood between them.

During a recent interview with Vulture, Jennifer Love Hewitt said she hasn’t spoken to her “ I Know What You Did Last Summer ” co-star Sarah Michelle Gellar since the slasher debuted in 1997.

According to Cline, the nightmarish sequence itself was not a part of the original script, but it was eventually added during the rehearsal phase of production.