When it comes to the best superhero movies of all time, plenty of stellar films are in the running. Marvel and DC both have massive cinematic universes to consider, and they are both entering exciting new eras.

Superhero movies have evolved from cult fandom to international fixation—and let’s be honest, everybody’s got a favorite. But to put settling arguments over which cape-wearing heroes fly, Rotten Tomatoes is now the web’s answer scoreboard.